Secrets of the Kashmir Valley: My journey through the conflict between India and Pakistan
Author: Farhana Qazi
Publisher: Pharos Media & Publishing Pvt Ltd. New Delhi, India
Year of Publication: 2016
Price: Rs 300
Reviewed by Mushtaq Ul Haq Ahmad Sikander
Kashmir Issue and its dynamics have engaged a lot of minds since the birth of the present dispute in 1947. The independent state of Jammu & Kashmir as it existed before the partition of the subcontinent couldn’t save itself from the violence and political ruckus going around. It also had to bear the brunt of the politics going around and got partitioned with one part being administered by Pakistan and other by India. The history writing of Kashmir too got mired with conflicting narratives from the Indian and Pakistani historians. The Kashmiri historians too couldn’t save themselves from these influences. Very few narratives have been written about the contribution of women to the political, economic, resistance and conflict arenas of contemporary Kashmir. Kashmir has been described as a territory of desire and its natural beauty has been rendered synonymous with the beauty of its women. Kashmir Ki Kali(Flower of Kashmir) used as a metaphor was supposed to be the heartthrob of every South Asian man and was an exotic theme for Bollywood Directors in the 1970s and 1980s. Kashmir famed for its beauty is synonymous with the Paradise on Earth not only for what nature has bestowed on her in the form of snowed pecked mountains, gushing rivers, green endless meadows, gorgeous waterfalls, but also the beauty whose repositories are the damsels, lasses and maidens of Kashmir and this beauty is dynamic unlike the other forms of static ones. As is the norm with every beauty various forces cast their evil eyes on it, resulting in wither of the kali. Now the lass, damsel and maiden of Kashmir neither is revered as Kali nor likes to be attributed as Kali; she takes pride in being associated and related to the dead, Shaheed Ki behen, Shaheed Ki Maa, Shaheed ki beti, Shaheed ki Bewa (Sister of a martyr, Mother of a martyr, Daughter of a martyr, Widow of a martyr).
Women of Kashmir enjoyed an envious status in the ancient and early medieval period of Kashmir. They ruled Kashmir alongwith men, Queen Didda, Kota Rani are the best examples of the same. Kashmir had its own crop of women poets like Habba Khatoon who was also the Queen of the last deposed King of Kashmir Yousuf Shah Chak, who was forced to die in exile by Mughal emperor Akbar. Gnostic, Mystic Poet Lalla Aarifah or Lalleshwari (Lal Ded or Lal Mouj) the former used by Muslims and latter by Hindus to describe her, though she didn’t convert to Islam but was deeply influenced by its fundamentals and tenants espousing humanity, fraternity, equality and communal harmony.
The present book under review as the tagline of the book suggests relates to the number of journeys undertaken by non resident kashmiri author, Farhana Qazi to trace her roots as well as relate the ordeal of women in Indian and Pakistan administered Kashmir, who are bearing the brunt of violent conflict, that is raging around them. The eminent scholar, Victoria Schofield who is author of number of books on Kashmir in her Foreword lauds the resilience and extraordinary endurance of common Kashmiris who despite suffering for more than seven decades a political fiasco are still struggling to decide their political future. In her Introduction, Farhana Qazi describes the purpose of her book as, “This book is an oral history of women and their men. It is a series of stories of by ordinary Kashmiris living extraordinary lives in an active conflict. It is an attempt to make the invisible women and their men known to the outside world” (P-28).
This oral history begins with her description of Kashmir valley at night, where army troopers after every few hundred meters demand the reason for travelling at night. She relates the daily trails and tribulations of common people by turning nostalgic relating the narrative of her mother and grandmother who were a part of Kashmiri culture and its history before her parents migrated to United States of America. She tries to relate the topography of Kashmir to Texas where Qazi is presently based. She relates with keen observation the daily routine of common women that rarely finds mention in the historical narratives written about women. Instead of ridiculing Kashmiris for their opportunistic behaviour, nepotism, selfishness or cunning nature as previous historians have generalized with ease, she has words of genuine appreciation for Kashmiris. “Kashmiris had the ability to mask their pain by offering a radiant, welcoming smile to outsiders, endowing food and gifts on to anyone who stumbled into the valley- a Buddhist, Christian, Hindu, Jew. Sixty plus years of conflict had left its people unchanged-their heart-filled hospitality remained open to all visitors” (P-90). This is a very correct description of Kashmiris because despite suffering in the highest militarized zone of the world, the humanity, pluralism, communal harmony and hospitality has not left Kashmiris.
She has related the stories of a number of women, who are active in resistance, have bore its brunt as mothers, sisters, daughters and suffered because of their gender. She relates the ordeal of Saadia, a suicide bomber in making. The agonizing tales of mothers whose sons have been rendered to enforced disappearances in the custody of security forces. These Mothers have not given up the hope of finding the reality of their sons and bringing guilty to the book. The caged souls of Aasiya Andrabi, Anjum Zamrudas Habib and Fareeda Behenji also find mention in the narratives who time and again were incarcerated particularly in the notorious jail of Tihar in Delhi, away from home and hearth. The illegal detention and arrests of common protesting women are described too. Rape as a weapon of war for curtailing the resistance against Indian state has been time and again used by the army and police against women that certainly has devastating impact over their lives. “For young Kashmiri girls, and single women, the stigma of rape also ruined their chances of marriage. Many girls secluded themselves inside their homes. When the shame became too great to bear, some girls committed suicide. The overpowering feelings of shame made these girls feel like unwanted members of society” (P-109). None of the security forces guilty of rape have been punished as they are provided impunity under the draconian law of Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA).
Qazi’s book is unique in this respect as she provides a glimpse of the problems and issues that women face in Pakistan administered Kashmir. She aptly describes the conditions of wives of militants and how they survive, the mental state of wives of men who are ready to sneak in the valley to fight for the freedom of Kashmir. She further describes the refugee families, their unique problems, the desire of some to return back to valley, their daily problems including power cuts, delay in ration supplies, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and how it has taken its toll on women. The 2008-2010 Intifada, Afzal Guru hanging and the devastating floods of 2014 also find mention in the book. Despite being a genuine attempt at understanding and analyzing the problems of women by using the methodology of oral history Qazi, gets it wrong in many places that certainly could have been avoided if the research aspect of the book would have been paid a serious heed. The claim that Kashmiris boycotted 1987 elections and then quoting Prem Nath Bazaz is utterly wrong (P-74), because Prem Nath Bazaz died in 1984 much before these elections were held, and kashmiris participated in good numbers in that election because they were trying to make Muslim United Front (MUF) candidates successful. On P-186, the Kubrawi Sufi Mir Sayyid Ali Hamdani has been described as King of Kashmir, it is a sheer mistake. He is popularly known as Shah e Hamdan meaning King of Hamdan, metaphorically used by Kashmiris, otherwise in reality he never held power or was a king. Further on P-201 it is incorrectly mentioned that Zubin Mehta’s show was supposed to be held at Lal Chowk.
Rest the book is an important addition to the rare literature available about women in conflict. Further Qazi has verve to describe a political narrative with a personal tinge that makes the reader feel emphatic towards the narrator. This book cannot be missed by any serious reader on Kashmir conflict. A must read indeed.
Mushtaq Ul Haq Ahmad Sikander is Writer-Activist based in Srinagar, Kashmir and can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org